Upside Down Square Pie
Sauce ladled over the cheese, Sicilian style. The famous slice across local listings and reviews.
Sauce on top of the cheese, served late every night. Call ahead and it is hot when you walk in.
Four pies regulars talk about. Names come from public menu listings and customer reviews.
Sauce ladled over the cheese, Sicilian style. The famous slice across local listings and reviews.
The loaded square. A listed customer favorite with the full topping treatment.
Thin square with bright sauce. Reviewers single it out as a standout order.
The namesake cheese pie. Plain, crisp, and built for a crowd.
Every category below is confirmed on public menu listings. Item names only.
Prices at the counter. Public listings disagree on prices and some figures look out of date, so nothing is printed here. Call for the current numbers.
Takeout friendly. Reviewers say the pies freeze and reheat well, and one July 2026 reviewer reports having food delivered.
| Mon to Thu | 10:00 AM to 1:00 AM |
|---|---|
| Fri to Sat | 10:00 AM to 2:00 AM |
| Sunday | 10:00 AM to 1:00 AM |
No online ordering page could be verified for this shop, so the phone is the way to order.
Reviewed on One Bite. Same-name shops also trade in Brooklyn and Port Washington; this page covers Maspeth only.
The dining room was recently renovated and made more spacious, per the shop's directory listing. Regulars mention crispy crusts and a flavorful sauce.